STATE COLLEGE, Pa. (AP) — Getting Penn State coach Joe Paterno and Pitt counterpart Dave Wannstedt on the same campus is a rarity. Getting them to back the same idea is practically a coup.
Pennsylvania football’s highest-profile college coaches are lending their support to high school coaches seeking to add a spring football practice period — an idea that has been around for a while, but has never gained traction with the PIAA, the governing body for Pennsylvania scholastic sports.
Skeptics remain and the PIAA this week offered a lukewarm response, though backers of the idea hope to get a boost with JoePa and Wannstedt now on board.
“Absolutely,” Paterno responded when asked if he would support a measure before the PIAA to install a spring football period.
Three members of the Pennsylvania Scholastic Football Coaches Association traveled to Penn State this week to garner the support of Paterno and Wannstedt. Temple coach Al Golden could not attend because of a scheduling conflict.
“Now we’re trying to put some action behind the talk,” said Red Land coach Frank Gay, one of the PSFCA emissaries, about spring practice. “It’s something that we felt we needed the support of Coach Wannstedt, Coach Paterno and Coach Golden because they see it, and that will give us some meat behind our argument.”
States like Texas and Florida already have spring practice periods. A spring period would not only hone the skills of developing high school players, but also get perhaps second-tier players not drawing attention from Division I schools more recruiting looks from Division II, III or Ivy League schools, said Clearfield coach Tim Janocko.
At issue are full-contact spring practices, similar to the spring drills held at Penn State and Pitt. The PIAA in December allowed schools for the first time to let players wear pads during spring workouts, though physical contact is not allowed.
“We’re inching closer,” Gay said. “If we’re going to get to that level, why don’t we just get it over with and do it that right way?”
The high school coaches would like a spring practice period in late May, mainly toward the end of track and baseball seasons.
“We all know how many repetitions it takes for a young man to develop a skill,” Wannstedt said, “and the more that he can get an opportunity to do that, the better opportunity he has to improve his skills and better his opportunity to be a better player and go to college somewhere.”
Paterno said his support has nothing to do with giving Penn State a recruiting advantage.
“But there are a bunch of kids that are this close, and with a little coaching, a little encouragement, a little pride in some things, they can do well and make a difference,” he said.
Getting the PIAA to approve a spring practice period may be challenging even with the high-profile support.
PIAA executive director Brad Cashman, in interviews this week with several reporters, cited a PIAA bylaw that states a sport could not operate at the detriment to other sports. In Pennsylvania, a potential spring practice period could interfere with track, volleyball, lacrosse, baseball and tennis.
“We don’t see it happening, and mostly because it will be a detriment to the five other spring sports,” PIAA assistant executive director Melissa Mertz said Friday.
To approve spring practice, the PIAA would also have to amend the bylaw. The last time the topic came up was in 2000, when it was voted down by a PIAA football steering committee, Mertz said.
The PIAA is also concerned that allowing full-contact drills outside of the fall would put more players at risk for concussions, Mertz said.
The PIAA, she added, has also “always been a proponent of letting kids be part of as many (activities) as possible,” she said. “We don’t think high school is a time to specialize. Some will do it, and that’s fine ... but we will always try to promote from this office always getting involved in several activities.”
A late May football period could conflict with multi-sport athletes in the state track meet or state baseball playoffs, “but when we look at the numbers, it’s not that many,” Gay said.
Athletes at schools with smaller enrollments may have more difficult choices. For instance, about three-quarters of the 60-70 football players at Selinsgrove participate in spring sports, said Brian Catherman, a track coach who will become athletic director this summer.
Catherman said the spring football practice issue hasn’t come up at Selinsgrove, which excels at track and won the Class AAA football title last season. Catherman also likes his students to play as many sports as they like. Football players working on speed run track, and linemen needing practice with footwork take part in field events.
“When you tell athletes you have to pick, well that’s not really fair to them,” Catherman said.
6 comments:
"Brad Cashman, in interviews this week with several reporters, cited a PIAA bylaw that states a sport could not operate at the detriment to other sports."
What a line of B.S. They only use this rule when its to their advantage, like now. If this bylaw is so important, why do they let football in the state run through the middle of December and interfere with Basketball season? What about sports like Baseball and Track that run congruent? Kids have to make a choice there dont they? The PIAA is just against change...and they cant make any money off of spring practices so they dont think its a major issue. Meanwhile, states like Florida, Texas, and California have been doing this for years and their talent, quite frankly, is out pacing ours. And to make the argument that this will lead to more injuries is absurd. Kids cant get hurt playing baseball or running track? They contradict themselves in every argument that they make. I guarantee if you took a poll of high school football players in this state more than 80% would be in favor of this.
Football is the only sport that is hammered with all these restrictions. You can play baseball in the fall, basketball in the summer and soccer whenever the hell you want to. If your argument is you don't want students to have to pick, then eliminate the out of season competitions for the other sports. Our state used to be the best in the USA for NCAA recruiting. Now it is falling behind Ohio, Texas, California and Florida because of the PIAA's ignorance.
The summer baseball, softball and volleyball teams are travel teams that have nothing to do with the school. If someone started a Summer Football League, similar to softball and baseball traveling teams how could they stop the kids from playing.
You are wrong about the summer football league. A few years ago Tim O'Malley sent out a warning to schools to make sure their players avoided certain football camps that went in full gear or pro gear with contact. His statement said if players attended these camps, their eligibility would be in jeopardy. Now, these are private camps and college camps, so if they are stretching the no-contact rule to those lengths, a summer league doesn't have a prayer. All things are not equal.
That is the case because the players attend these camps with their high school coaches.
Off-season baseball and basketball teams are not run by the high school coaches. They may be somebody affiliated with the program, but it's a loophole.
As for Texas, Florida, California and others passing Pennsylvania, that has little to do with off-season practices and more to do with population.
You are wrong. It has nothing to do with coaches attending with them! I am talking about camps that parents pay for and take their kids to. The WPIAL will deem an athlete ineligible if they take part in ANY organized practices or games that involve contact. How can you say year round participation does not affect a players performance/abilities? Sure, our population is down, but when other states are getting twice as much gametime, they are increasing their odds of playing at the next level.
Post a Comment